Lakshmikumaran and Sridharan logo
b

Input Tax Credit availability to bona fide purchaser when supplier defaults – Section 16(2)(c) is constitutionally valid but mechanical denial of ITC is wrong

03 Nov 20262 min read

The Punjab & Haryana High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017, which makes availability of Input Tax Credit (ITC) contingent upon actual payment of tax by the supplier to the Government. The Court, however, held that GST authorities cannot mechanically deny or reverse ITC merely because a supplier has defaulted in tax payment, filed nil returns, or had its registration cancelled retrospectively.

The High Court in its decision in Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. v. Union of India also laid down extensive safeguards requiring tax authorities to examine the genuineness of transactions, investigate the supplier's default, consider recovery proceedings against the supplier, and provide a reasoned opportunity of hearing before denying ITC to bona fide purchasers. The following was observed for the purpose:

  • ITC is a statutory concession and the condition that tax must actually reach the Government is integral to the GST framework. Section 16(2)(c) itself is constitutionally valid.

  • Sections 42 and 43, which were designed to enable invoice matching and alert recipients of supplier defaults, were never implemented. Therefore, purchasers have no practical means to verify whether suppliers have deposited tax.

  • Taxpayers' grievances arise from the routine and mechanical application of Section 16(2)(c), rather than from the wording of the provision.

  • Imposing tax liability on a purchaser who has already paid tax to the supplier, without examining surrounding facts, could lead to unjust outcomes and potential double taxation.

  • Section 76 provides a remedy against defaulting suppliers. Authorities cannot ignore those provisions and proceed directly against purchasers in every case.

  • Supplier’s retrospective cancellation of registration, nil returns or departmental alerts may justify investigation, but cannot by themselves form the basis for ITC denial to purchaser.

  • Fraud of the supplier cannot automatically be attributed to the purchaser.

  • Tax invoices, e-way bills, transport documents, weighbridge slips, stock records and proof of receipt of goods must be considered before adverse action is taken.

  • Purchaser’s registration cannot be cancelled merely because suppliers' registrations were later cancelled. Independent grounds under Section 29(2) must exist before cancelling a purchaser's GST registration.

  • The Court directed officers to apply the statutory framework applicable to the relevant period, especially distinguishing the periods before and after introduction of amended Section 41 and Rule 37A.

One of the assessees was represented by Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan Attorneys here.

Related Articles

Check out our GST knowledge portal
Was this useful?

Discuss this topic with our GST Consultancy team

Contact Us
CallEmail